home / library / newsletters / valuation report



 
Fall, 2006
In this issue:

Steep IRS Penalties Deter Valuation Misstatements

Are valuations merely a good guess? According to the Internal Revenue Service, they better not be. When it comes to estate and gift taxes, the value of what’s being transferred is an integral part of the tax liability equation. To underscore the importance of using valid valuation numbers, the IRS has serious penalties and sanctions in place, which discourage significant overvaluation or undervaluation. And as of August 17, 2006, the IRS has tightened these restrictions even further.

How to Make the Most of Expert Witnesses
Divorce. Fraud. Business disputes. When issues of value end up in court, accountants often end up in court, too — as expert witnesses. Attorneys for both sides call on CPAs to offer their professional opinions about the value of whatever is in dispute.

When the Numbers Get Ugly —
Forensic Accounting May Uncover Hidden Earnings

When applying for a loan or courting an investor, a business owner generally wants to make his or her business look especially attractive. But there are times when a business owner might actually benefit from having the business appear to be less valuable than it really is.

Credentials Check

With more and more accountants entering the valuation arena, it’s important to know the background and training of the professionals you may hire. Ask for references, and look for certifications showing that they are trained valuation experts.

 

 

Summer, 2006
In this issue:

Start Early When Planning to Sell

Five years. That’s the minimum amount of time a business owner needs to plan his or her exit from a company. Five years of intense planning will give most owners time to assess the state of the company and take the steps necessary to maximize its value.

How to Value Contingent Assets & Liabilities

To arrive at a proper valuation, business analysts gather thousands of data points about a subject company. Much of the relevant information is easy to find, but some crucial pieces are a challenge to uncover and assess. Contingent assets and liabilities fall into the latter category.

Excess Value:
Handling Assets Above and Beyond the Earnings Stream

Every business requires assets to generate income, but some companies have more assets than they need. Should these additional assets be included in the value of the company? As every valuation expert will tell you, “It depends.”

Price v. Value — What’s the Difference?

Consider this scenario: You’re a growing manufacturer. One of your direct competitors decides to sell his business, and you are approached about buying it.


 

 

Spring, 2006
In this issue:

Discounts for Lack of Marketability — A New Approach

If it’s not liquid, what’s it really worth? That’s the question behind the concept of discounts for lack of marketability. A marketability discount applied to the estimated value of a business is designed to reflect the fact that shares in a privately held company are less liquid than in a publicly traded company. The less liquid the asset, the lower its value.

Buy-Sell Agreements:
What You Need to Know About Their Effect on Value


According to the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania, only about one-third of closely held businesses survive into the second generation. Lack of planning is often the reason for failure — and a good buy-sell agreement can make all the difference.

How to Get at the Heart of Healthcare Company Valuations

Healthcare company valuations often seem as complex as brain surgery. In many cases, the main challenge is pinning down revenue forecasts, which can be a moving target in healthcare.

AICPA Proposes Valuation Standards

As members of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA), CPAs are governed by the organization’s rules and standards. Last year, the AICPA proposed standards for valuation services with the goal of improving consistency and quality. Once adopted, these AICPA standards would guide all CPAs who perform valuations.

 

 

Winter 2006
In this issue:

Complex Rules Dictate Accounting for Intangible Assets

In the world of mergers and acquisitions, the Financial Accounting Standards Board’s (FASB) Statements of Financial Accounting Standards (SFAS) 141 and 142 certainly changed the landscape. Fair value measurement is in, pooling of interests is out…the purchase method is in, amortization is out…impairment testing is in… You get the picture.

Demystifying the Discount Rate

As business valuation experts, we talk a lot about discount rates. But what are they? And how do we arrive at them?

Gift vs. Estate Taxes:
Is It Always Better to Give …?


Maybe it’s true that it is better to give than to receive. But when to give is a question that tax and valuation experts often ponder. Should an asset be gifted during the owner’s lifetime to reduce the value of his or her estate? Or should the owner hold onto a particular asset and gift another one?

FLP Do’s and Don’ts

Over the past few years, Family Limited Partnerships (FLPs) have become popular financial planning tools. Typically, an individual transfers assets to an FLP and transfers ownership of limited partnership interests to family members. Because the transferred interest is normally not controlling and not readily marketable, valuation discounts apply, reducing the value for estate and gift tax purposes.

 

 

Fall 2005
In this issue:

Selling A Business? Consider Personal Goodwill

As a business owner, it’s all about you. Or is it?

Litigation Outlook:
Estate Tax Rulings Underscore Importance of Expertise


Who’s winning in tax court? Michael Gregory, an IRS employee and valuation expert, recently conducted a study comparing the statistics of recent tax court rulings with those of a prior era. His findings suggest that the courts are now less likely to “split the difference” in litigation, and are instead leaning more toward a “one-side-wins” result.

Valuing Manufacturing Companies:
Valuation Measures That Make a Difference


Outsourcing…environmental concerns…trade agreements…fuel costs. These issues have affected every U.S. industry, but perhaps none so dramatically as manufacturing.

How to Add Value with Contact Spheres

Everyone knows about the value of networking, especially in professional services businesses where personal referrals are often the largest source of new business. But does your company really make the most of networking opportunities?
 

 

Summer 2005
In this issue:

Marketability Discounts —Quantifying A Lack of Liquidity

According to business valuation guru Shannon Pratt, marketability discounts are often among the largest money issues in a disputed business valuation.

“C” to “S” — Plan Carefully to Avoid Built-In Gains

Thinking of changing corporate status from a C to an S corporation? Unlike a C corporation, an S corporation generally does not pay a federal corporate income tax. Instead, the taxable income of the corporation is reported on the returns of its individual stockholders.

The Ups & Downs of Construction Company Valuations

Construction contractors are accustomed to being at the mercy of the U.S. economy. The industry enjoyed strong growth in 2004, and new construction starts in 2005 look promising. But demand is highly cyclical, and revenues and expenses are uneven. Whether the company is a general building, highway or residential contractor, these valuation vagaries add to the challenge of appraising a construction company.

Litigation Outlook: Forensic Investigations in Divorce

Divorce isn’t pretty. But sometimes it’s downright ugly, with spouses hiding income, deflating business values or otherwise trying to diminish whatever could potentially be divided between them.


 

 

Spring 2005
In this issue:

AICPA Rules Impact Business Valuation

Since Congress enacted the Sarbanes-Oxley Act in 2002, CPAs have been working under a new set of rules for audit clients. In order to avoid conflicts of interest and maintain independence, firms providing audit services are precluded from providing certain other services to their publicly held audit clients, including appraisal or valuation services.

Litigation Update —
Family Limited Partnerships Face New Challenges

Will Family Limited Partnerships (FLPs) survive? Recent Tax Court decisions show that the IRS has continued its intense scrutiny of FLPs and their discounts, with a big push to disqualify them under IRC 2036(a). 2004 brought some interesting decisions:

TrendWatch 2005:
A Look at Professional Service Firm Valuations

Professional service firms used to be “different.” Traditionally, they were run by the people with their names on the door. They often lacked the structured policies and procedures of other types of companies. They relied purely on their service expertise to distinguish themselves in the marketplace, with little advertising or marketing to help them along.

BV Experts & Attorneys: Partnerships in Action

CPAs and attorneys have long been allies, counting on each other for specific expertise to help their clients. As professional specialization deepens in both the legal and accounting professions, these informal partnerships have become more important than ever.


 

 

Winter 2005
In this issue:

Standards of Value — Which One Works When?

Consider a toddler’s tattered blanket. What is its value?

The Do’s and Don’ts of FLPs

Family Limited Partnerships (FLPs) have long been popular business and estate planning tools. Because assets in an FLP are excluded from a person’s estate, an FLP can substantially reduce the estate’s value and transfer or gift taxes.

Reduce Risk to Enhance Value

How much control does an owner have over the value of his or her business? As always, it depends on the business. Value is based on a combination of marketability and risk factors. Traditional wisdom dictates that more risk equals less value.

The Benefits of Joint Appointments

Money is often a core issue in family law cases. So the idea of saving money by hiring one valuation expert for both parties is becoming increasingly popular around the country.
 

 

Fall, 2004
In this issue:

Gross v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
S Corp Earnings - To Tax-Affect or Not?



For many years, valuation professionals thought the rules on tax-affecting earnings of S corporations were straightforward. The standard was set. Tax-affecting was the appropriate course of action so that the pre-tax earnings of S corporations could be fairly assessed relative to the post-tax earnings of C corporations, which are the basis for well-established rates of return.

Litigation Outlook:
Making the Most of Cross-Examination


Many business valuation experts spend a lot of time working on behalf of their clients in litigation. In cases of divorce, shareholder oppression or economic damages, a business valuator often serves as an expert witness in a deposition or trial, defending the valuation report as fair, impartial and accurate.

The Big Deal About Personal Goodwill

Personal goodwill gets a lot of attention in cases of divorce. But it's often overlooked as a personal asset in purchase price allocations - a costly mistake.

Value Variables: Know the Warning Signs

What creates value? As valuation experts, we base our work on expected returns and the risks associated with them. Everything else being equal, the riskier the company, the lower the value.
 

 

Summer, 2004
In this issue:

Bankruptcy Valuations Require Specialized Expertise

The dot-coms are gone. The steel industry is in its second cycle of bankruptcy, and the airline industry is not far behind. It looks like bankruptcy valuation experts and the attorneys with whom they work will be busy for a few years to come.

Fraud: Is It Getting Easier to Hide?

Computers have done great things for business efficiency. Unfortunately, they've also done great things for criminal efficiency. The Association of Fraud Examiners estimates that the average loss associated with computer-related fraud is $1.9 million, and that number continues to increase every year.

Business Valuation Reports: Which Type Do You Need?

Each valuation assignment is unique, and each engagement requires in-depth analysis and a thorough understanding of the business being valued. However, the findings can be reported in different ways, depending on the circumstances of the engagement.

How to Handle Subsequent Events

A business valuation represents a company's value at a specific point in time. But things can change quickly. How should a valuation accommodate events that take place subsequent to the valuation date but before the valuation has served its purpose?

 

 

Spring, 2004
In this issue:
Look for "Certifiable" Expertise

Courts and the IRS have become increasingly critical about the qualifications of "experts." When hiring a business valuation professional, look for someone with specific training and experience. In addition to checking references, check his or her credentials.


The Ins & Outs of Expert Testimony

Business valuators are frequently called upon to serve as expert witnesses in legal matters surrounding dissolution of marriage, lost profits, breach of contract, wrongful death and personal injury. If you are a lawyer involved in such a case - or the actual plaintiff or defendant - it is crucial that you know how to work with the business valuator during the legal proceedings to ensure that you are making the most of his or her expertise.

Sarbanes-Oxley:
Does It Affect Your Business Valuation Relationships?

In response to The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, the Securities and Exchange Commission adopted strict new standards regarding the independence of auditors working with public companies. The revised rules were designed to strengthen auditor independence regarding audit services, but they also had an impact on non-audit services: Public companies are now required to engage firms other than their outside auditors to perform certain non-audit services.

Estate of Strangi vs. Commissioner, Tax Court:
Tax Transfer Valuations - What Counts?

Has the IRS succeeded in negating some attractive estate-planning tax breaks afforded family limited partnerships? The latest ruling - Strangi II - has caused great debate.

 

 

Winter, 2004
In this issue:
Fraud Finders: Financial Statement Warning Signs

In our line of work, we spend a lot of time examining financial statements to help determine the value of a business. Unfortunately, financial statements are not always the credible documents they're intended to be. Sometimes we find clues that point to fraud - a deliberate attempt to inflate or deflate the financial position or profits of the company. Either way, the intention of fraud is to give an inaccurate impression of the company's position.

Valuing Seed- and Early-Stage Businesses: Experience Required

How does one determine the value of a business with a high degree of risk, little history, no operating profits and marginal revenue? This is the challenge faced by CPAs working with seed-stage or early-stage businesses. With so few answers and so many questions, the valuator must rely on a variety of techniques, many of which are outside traditional valuation methods.

Warning Signs of Fraud: A Quick Test

Concerned about financial statement fraud? If so, take this test. If you answer "yes" to many of these questions, further investigation may be warranted.

 

Fall 2003
In this issue:

Family Limited Partnerships Face New Tax Challenge

The generous tax breaks enjoyed by family limited partnerships face serious new threats, as a result of a recent U. S. Tax Court decision in Estate of Strangi v. Commissioner. In light of the ruling, estate planners are advising donors to reduce or relinquish control over family partnerships and operate them under very strict rules to avoid conflicts of interest and reduce the risk of an IRS challenge.

Protecting Intellectual Property From Potential Threats

For many companies, intellectual property constitutes a significant group of assets, including trademarks, patents, copyrights and trade secrets. By implementing certain internal policies and procedures long before a litigation event actually occurs, you can help your clients protect their claims to these assets.

Reconstructing a Complete Picture of Value

Professional valuators tackle each assignment with a blend of art and science…and sometimes solid detective work. The circumstances of the assignment will, of course, dictate the valuator’s approach. Depending on the nature of the assignment, and the type of value that is sought, the valuator may begin with a closer examination of historical financial information. In a divorce situation, tax returns sometimes point the way to more complete information. In a corporate situation, valuators need to carefully scrutinize any number of areas related to revenue.

 

 

 

Summer 2003
In this issue:

Planning Ahead Means a Better Value When It’s Time to Sell

Business owners can take a number of steps, given time, to enhance the value of their businesses. They may, for example want to upgrade their accounting practices to enhance the credibility of their financial statements. They should also conduct an overall review of their expenses. Additionally, they should review their borrowing to see if they can pay down or restructure any of their debt. In short, anything they can do to enhance, protect or stabilize revenue will pay off at sale.

Should Lower Rates Mean Higher Values?

With interest rates at historic lows, an obvious question is whether this low cost of capital has or should affect business valuations. While interest rates do need to be considered in valuations, they do not have nearly as significant an effect on business values as they do in other areas.

 

Discounts Still Appropriate in Multi-Tiered Entities

When valuing a multi-tiered entity, should control, marketability or other discounts apply at each level, or should these entities be valued as a whole without concern for constraints facing the individual components that comprise the entity. The answer? Every level of the entity should be valued independently and appropriate discounts should be applied at each level.

 

Spring 2003
In this issue:

Swing Vote Premium Hinges on Circumstances

Recent political history illustrates the importance of the swing vote concept. When Sen. Jim Jeffords of Vermont left the Republican party in May 2000 to become an independent, he represented only 1 percent of the voting power in the U.S. Senate. Yet his decision shifted control of the body from the Republicans to the Democrats. Sometimes less is more.

When you apply the swing vote concept to minority interests within a company, the same argument can apply.  Should, therefore, a premium be attached to these interests?

Forecasts and Projections: Understanding the Differences

Too often, accounting and business literature treats forecasts and projections as interchangeable terms, as different names for the same activities. Yet forecasts and projections differ both in scope and in the circumstances in which each is appropriate.
 

Forensic Experts, Valuation Professionals Can Both Help Fraud Victims

Many valuation professionals also perform forensic accounting engagements to help identify fraud. Both valuation and forensic engagements often use the same or similar methodologies, such as common size analyses. Where a valuation professional often takes management at its word, however, the fraud examiner checks everything.

 

Winter 2003
In this issue:

Valuation Issues in Bankruptcy: Signs of the Times
With many companies continuing to struggle, understanding the valuation issues involved in bankruptcy is more important than ever. Two types of values must be determined in association with bankruptcy proceedings: reorganization value and liquidation value.

Compensation Issues Complicate Valuations in Divorce Cases
In a divorce that involves a closely held business as one of the marital assets, determining the accurate value of the business is a key first step in determining the equitable distribution of marital assets between the parting spouses. An issue that frequently complicates that valuation is the question of reasonable compensation.

Getting Personal:  Understanding Goodwill Offers Real Benefits
Any business that depends to a considerable degree on the technical acumen, personal contacts, managerial skill, or operational expertise of an identifiable person likely has personal goodwill as a component of its value. Lawyers and others advising business owners in a wide variety of transactions should make a point of learning the many ways in which identifying personal goodwill can benefit their clients.

Tax Court Cases Underscore Importance of Control Issues


Two recent Tax Court cases underscore the importance of control –and lack of control – of assets when planning gifts and trusts.